The Indiana Pacers put the Oklahoma City Thunder on high alert during the 2025 NBA Finals, with T.J. McConnell emerging as an unexpected game-changer. Known for his crafty play, McConnell's performance in critical moments kept the Thunder on their toes, especially when they struggled with inbound passes. He averaged 12 points, 4.3 assists, 3.6 rebounds, and a remarkable 2.1 steals during the series, significantly contributing to the Pacers’ close run against the heavily favored Thunder.

With standout games in crucial moments, including multiple steals that disrupted the Thunder's rhythm, McConnell demonstrated his ability to influence the game without being a main scorer. His performance, alongside other role players like Obi Toppin and Pascal Siakam, reflected the collective effort that brought the Pacers within a win of their first NBA title.