LeBron James, drafted first overall by the Cleveland Cavaliers in 2003, quickly showcased his prowess, averaging 20.9 points, 5.5 rebounds, and 5.9 assists per game in his rookie season. Despite his accolades, including the Rookie of the Year title with 78 first-place votes, there was a strong case for Carmelo Anthony, who led the Denver Nuggets to the playoffs, a feat not matched by the Cavaliers. Anthony's impressive 21.0 points and playoff performance left some, including Tracy McGrady, questioning the award decision.

The disparity in team success during their rookie seasons fueled the debate. While James garnered praise for his individual talent, Anthony's leadership in transforming the Nuggets from a 17-win team the previous year to playoff contenders was notable. McGrady's remarks echo the sentiment that despite the accolades, the impact on team success should also weigh heavily in Rookie of the Year considerations.