In a disappointing first-round exit from the 2025 NBA playoffs, the Orlando Magic fell to the defending champions, the Boston Celtics, with a final score of 120-89. Despite Paolo Banchero's impressive performance of 19 points, nine rebounds, and six assists, his limited playing time due to foul trouble significantly impacted the team's chances. Banchero and fellow star Franz Wagner, who contributed 25 points, couldn't overcome the Celtics' dominance, and the Magic were eliminated for the second consecutive year.

Banchero's father voiced his frustration regarding the officiating which hindered his son's participation, while Banchero himself expressed confusion over unfair calls. Although this playoff run ended in disappointment, Banchero's overall postseason performance, averaging 29.4 points over five games, showed his growth as a player.