The Cincinnati Bengals shocked many by selecting edge rusher Shemar Stewart with the 17th overall pick in the 2025 draft. This choice raised eyebrows among analysts, including ESPN's Jordan Reid, who expressed concerns over Stewart's production in college, noting only four sacks across three seasons. The Bengals appear to be banking on his raw potential, hoping he can complement established players like Trey Hendrickson and Myles Murphy in a revamped defensive scheme under coordinator Al Golden.

Critics suggest that the Bengals might have opted for a more proven talent at this crucial position, especially given the need for immediate contributors. As the offseason progresses, the focus will shift to whether Stewart can develop into a reliable option opposite Hendrickson, and how this pick fits into the Bengals' broader strategy of balancing risk and potential in their roster management.