The Dallas Cowboys made a significant choice in the 2025 NFL Draft, selecting Tyler Booker, an offensive guard from Alabama, with the 12th overall pick. While some fans anticipated a splashier pick—potentially a playmaker such as a receiver or running back—Booker is lauded as a dominant force in his position, expected to step into the pivotal role vacated by the retiring Zack Martin. His selection reflects head coach Brian Schottenheimer's strategy of prioritizing high-character players with leadership qualities to cultivate a solid team culture.

Despite the optimism surrounding Booker’s potential, notable analyst Mel Kiper Jr. categorized the Cowboys as one of the “losers” of Round 1, citing the choice as a reach for a need. He expressed concerns regarding the value of selecting a guard at the 12th spot, especially when Dallas struggled with pass protection in the previous season. Kiper had previously ranked Booker at 25 on his prospect board, indicating that while the player is solid, the positional choice may not align with premium draft values.