The New York Giants emerged as notable winners in the 2025 NFL Draft, securing top-tier talent in edge rusher Abdul Carter from Penn State and quarterback Jaxson Dart. While the selections of Dart generated excitement for his franchise potential, they also raised eyebrows due to pre-draft evaluations placing him on Day 2 of the draft. Critics highlighted the Giants' choice of running back Cam Skattebo in the fourth round as questionable, pointing to concerns about his speed and big-play ability, despite his physicality and short-yardage skills.

Skattebo's ability as a role player offers the Giants a solid complement to established backs, including Tyrone Tracy Jr. Dart and Skattebo, could potentially solidify key positions for the team's future. Overall, the draft showcased the Giants' strategy to bolster their roster for sustained success while igniting discussions about the risk versus reward of their selections.