The New York Giants' general manager, Joe Schoen, faces a pivotal moment as the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, marking his fourth year in charge. This year's draft brings the option of extending the contracts of key first-round picks from his inaugural draft. Kayvon Thibodeaux, a standout edge rusher, will see his fifth-year option exercised, a testament to his potential. In contrast, the Giants have opted against extending the contract of Evan Neal. Once a highly touted offensive tackle, Neal has struggled with injuries and performance issues, ultimately losing his starting role to veteran Jermaine Eluemunor.

As the Giants navigate these critical decisions, they also welcome fifth-round pick Marcus Mbow to the offensive line mix. Mbow's addition complicates Neal's situation further, as he may need to transition positions. While Neal's skills in run blocking may facilitate a move to guard, the lingering issues in his pass protection remain a concern. The Giants are keen to evaluate Neal this season before deciding his future, with his status as a former first-round pick meaning a cut would incur significant dead cap. This creates an intense competition as Neal vies to prove he belongs on the roster, especially with new faces like Mbow, Josh Ezeudu, and others pushing for their spots.