The 2025 NFL Draft has wrapped up, and with it comes the annual analysis of picks that left fans perplexed. Among this year's first-round selections, five players stand out as potential mistakes.

At pick 6, the Las Vegas Raiders chose Ashton Jeanty, a highly talented running back, despite needing help on the offensive line and a stable quarterback. This decision raises eyebrows given that Josh Jacobs just departed in free agency, suggesting a missed opportunity to bolster other areas of a struggling team.

Meanwhile, Jaxson Dart was selected 25th by the New York Giants. Dart showed promise in college but lacks the elite traits of a franchise quarterback. His ceiling seems limited to moderate success, similar to that of Daniel Jones. Other teams might have opted for a safer option or a more proven commodity.

Matthew Golden, drafted 23rd by the Green Bay Packers, broke out late in college, yet his overall production raises questions about his ability to step into a WR1 role. He joins a crowded receiving corps without distinctly elevating the unit's talent level.

Josh Simmons, taken 32nd by the Kansas City Chiefs, brings physical tools but is viewed as a raw prospect. With an immediate need at tackle, many believe the Chiefs could have made a better choice with a more polished player. Lastly, Shemar Stewart, picked 17th by the Cincinnati Bengals, is noted for athleticism but showed limited production in college, leading to skepticism about whether he can make an impact at the professional level.

Abdul Carter, the standout outside linebacker for the New York Giants, is emerging as the favorite for the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award, currently listed at +250 by BETMGM. This puts him ahead of competitors like Travis Hunter (+750) and Jalon Walker, among others. Carter’s impressive college stats include 172 tackles and 23 sacks over three seasons, indicating his strong capability to pressure quarterbacks, a skill he is expected to translate to the NFL effectively.

The Giants' roster also boasts strong defensive players such as Kayvon Thibodeaux and Dexter Lawrence II, which might complicate Carter's path to consistent playing time. However, his versatility as a pass rusher could make him essential to the Giants' defensive scheme as they strive to improve their performance this season.

The New York Giants are looking to improve their tight end position after a lackluster 2024 season. Rookie Theo Johnson struggled with just 331 yards and one touchdown, hindered by subpar quarterback play. With Johnson set to start again, the Giants have added Nebraska's Thomas Fidone II to compete for depth. At his introductory press conference, Fidone expressed optimism about his chances to develop and contribute on special teams, albeit with limited expectations for playing time in year one.

While Fidone’s athleticism is promising, he may struggle with blocking, which could limit his on-field role. With Chris Manhertz serving as a reliable blocker and Daniel Bellinger providing depth, Fidone will need to prove himself in training camp to secure a spot on the roster. The Giants are optimistic about his competitiveness and work ethic, but expectations should remain low for the rookie tight end heading into the season.

The 2025 NFL Draft has concluded, and a re-draft reveals intriguing changes, especially beyond the top 10 picks. The Tennessee Titans maintain their choice of Cam Ward as the first overall pick, while the Jacksonville Jaguars stick with Travis Hunter at No. 2. The New York Giants select Abdul Carter at No. 3, and the New England Patriots retain Will Campbell at No. 4, ensuring they address critical needs. However, shifts occur later in the first round, with teams reconsidering their strategies based on the latest insights and performances.

The re-draft highlights the significance of maximizing value for teams, particularly regarding offensive line help for the Indianapolis Colts and defensive needs for the Cincinnati Bengals. Notably, the Giants pivot to selecting Tyler Shough, a quarterback from Louisville, at No. 25, indicating a potential change in direction for the franchise. Overall, the re-draft exercise showcases teams' flexibility and willingness to adapt as they head into OTAs and the upcoming season.

The 2024 college football season was notably marked by the emergence of several teams in the College Football Playoff, most prominently the Penn State Nittany Lions, who made it to the semifinals before narrowly losing to the Notre Dame Fighting Irish. Other teams such as the Boise State Broncos and Arizona State Sun Devils also made their playoff debuts, with Arizona State's Cam Skattebo shining as a standout running back. His impressive stats, including over 1,700 rushing yards and 21 touchdowns, earned him a spot on the New York Giants' roster in the 2025 NFL Draft. College football analyst David Pollack praised the Sun Devils' quarterback Sam Leavitt, calling him a potential star. Leavitt's first-year performance was impressive, throwing for nearly 3,000 yards and securing a Big 12 championship, signaling that Arizona State's future is bright.