Anthony Stolarz's season ended abruptly after sustaining a concussion in Game 1 of the Toronto Maple Leafs' playoff series against the Florida Panthers. The incident involved a collision with Panthers' forward Sam Bennett. Although Stolarz initially continued playing, he soon experienced severe symptoms, leading to his hospitalization. This untimely injury prevented him from contributing further to his team's playoff run, a significant setback given his impressive regular-season performance, where he led the NHL with a .926 save percentage.

Reflecting on the incident, Stolarz noted that he did not believe Bennett's hit was intentional and expressed disappointment at not being able to fulfill his postseason potential after a solid year. He dressed as backup for Game 7 despite his injury, underscoring his commitment to the team amidst personal challenges.