The Toronto Maple Leafs faced a dire situation, relinquishing a commanding 3-0 series lead to a precarious 3-2 against the Ottawa Senators. The performance was described as gutless, drawing frustration from fans and analysts alike. Key players, including Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner, failed to produce in elimination games, with Matthews particularly criticized for a lackluster showing on a night that demanded urgency. Questions arise regarding the team's mental fortitude and their notorious playoff struggles, with concerns that the ghosts of past failures haunt them during critical moments.

Defensively, the Leafs showed some resilience, limiting scoring chances yet unable to capitalize offensively. This compounded the anxiety surrounding their playoff legacy, as their inability to secure a win in elimination scenarios continues to taint their reputation. With game six looming, the pressure mounts for the Leafs to regain composure and deliver a performance that reflects their talent, rather than the distress of past failures.