Entering Week 15 of the 2025 fantasy baseball season, several high-profile players are struggling, leaving fantasy managers questioning their next moves. Paul Goldschmidt of the New York Yankees started strong but has since faltered dramatically, hitting just .170 with limited power. His time on the bench and poor performance against right-handed pitchers signal a need to sell. Tyler Soderstrom of the Oakland Athletics has been inconsistent but maintains strong power metrics, warranting a hold in deeper leagues despite recent slumps.

Jac Caglianone, a top prospect for the Kansas City Royals, is experiencing a rough adjustment to the majors, hitting .148 in his first 115 plate appearances. Managers should be patient with him, holding for potential improvement. On the pitching side, Atlanta Braves' Spencer Schwellenbach is facing a significant injury setback, making him a candidate to sell in all formats due to uncertainty about his return this season. Lastly, Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe's ongoing struggles may lead to dropping him in 12-team leagues unless stolen bases are a critical need.