The Cleveland Guardians are at a crossroads as the MLB trade deadline approaches. They sit 11.5 games behind in the AL Central but are only 3 games out of a Wild Card spot, making their decision to buy or sell quite complex. Selling top players could be wise if they receive compelling offers, yet adding a player like Cedric Mullins from the Baltimore Orioles might bolster their lineup. Mullins, although having lost some speed, could be a plug-and-play option that enhances their chances of a postseason run.

Despite their current standing, the Guardians still see potential in making a late-season push. This uncertain position reflects the delicate balance teams must navigate during this pivotal time of year, weighing immediate performance against future potential.