Pope Leo XIV's recent appearance in a White Sox cap has left many Cubs fans reeling, sparking a crisis of faith among the Northsiders. For years, the Cubs have been a symbol of hope and loyalty, especially after their historic World Series win in 2016. The Pope's allegiance to the South Side team feels like a betrayal to those who were raised to believe in the Cubs' supremacy. Yet, as the author suggests, this may not be a definitive statement of infallibility; after all, the Pope's expertise lies in spiritual matters, not baseball.

Historical context reveals a deeper connection between the Cubs and the Pope. The Cubs were once known as the Chicago White Stockings when the papacy formally recognized its infallibility in 1870, the same year the Cubs were established. The duality of fandom in Chicago is not just a matter of rivalry; it’s woven into the very fabric of the city’s heritage.