Drafting a catcher can be a daunting task in fantasy baseball, especially when some highly drafted players may not provide the value expected. Adley Rutschman, ranked as the second catcher in drafts, struggled significantly in the second half of 2024, hitting just .207 with a poor OPS. His declining bat speed and inability to handle right-handed pitching raise concerns about his performance moving forward. Will Smith also faced challenges, with rising strikeout rates indicating a potential decline as he approached 30. J.T. Realmuto's age is showing, with decreased power and stolen bases, suggesting a shift towards younger options may be prudent. Keibert Ruiz and Tyler Stephenson present additional risks with poor performance metrics that question their fantasy viability. The catcher's landscape is shifting, encouraging fantasy managers to explore alternatives for value.