As the 2025 fantasy baseball season reaches Week 10, several high-profile players have struggled significantly, raising the question of whether to drop, sell, or hold them. This week’s analysis focuses on five such players, all rostered in over 50% of Yahoo! leagues. Brandon Pfaadt of the Arizona Diamondbacks, once a promising pitcher, has seen his ERA skyrocket to 8.10 after allowing 24 earned runs in his last month, making him a candidate to sell low. Walker Buehler of the Boston Red Sox, returning from injury, has failed to regain his form, and fantasy managers may consider dropping him due to poor matchups ahead.

Meanwhile, Hunter Goodman from the Colorado Rockies has been inconsistent, batting just .157 in his last 14 games, suggesting a drop in 12-team leagues. Kyle Stowers of the Miami Marlins started strong but is in a slump, yet his overall numbers warrant holding for now. Adolis Garcia of the Texas Rangers, once a top power hitter, is struggling, making him another candidate for selling low. Each player presents unique challenges for fantasy managers as they navigate trades or roster adjustments.