Nolan Mlan anchored the rotation, delivering eight strong starts with a 2.06 ERA and an A+ breakout that reshaped the Mets’ 2025 narrative. Peterson carried early reliability but faded late, finishing with a solid B overall. Holmes logged the most innings (31 starts) with a 3.53 ERA and a reliable floor, earning a B. Sena and McGill flashed upside but were hobbled by injuries or late-season slumps, posting mid-range marks. Blackburn flopped, Tong and Maniah struggled, and the rotation’s depth plan proved costly.