Manager Dave Roberts faced an unprecedented challenge at the All-Star Game after the National League's ninth-inning lead evaporated, leading to the inaugural "swing-off" home run derby. Roberts selected sluggers Eugenio Suárez, Kyle Schwarber, and Pete Alonso to compete, with Kyle Stowers as an alternate. Despite an injury to Suárez, Stowers stepped in for the swing-off. Schwarber delivered a clutch performance with three consecutive home runs, securing the MVP award and giving the NL a 4-3 victory, marking just their fifth win in 28 All-Star Games.

The game featured standout performances from various players, including a solid strikeout display from pitcher Paul Skenes. The NL jumped to an early lead, with Ronald Acuña Jr. contributing with an infield hit. The game became more exciting in the later innings, especially when the AL mounted a comeback, but ultimately fell short as the NL prevailed in the dramatic finale.