Following a disheartening loss to the Athletics, the New York Yankees have made a roster move, sending Allan Winans to Triple-A. Winans struggled in his last two outings, culminating in an 8.53 ERA, raising concerns about his ability to hold a spot in the rotation. With Marcus Stroman set to return from injury, the Yankees are hoping his veteran experience can stabilize the rotation, despite his own struggles earlier this season, including an 11.57 ERA.

Stroman's activation comes after a long absence due to knee inflammation, and while his rehab performance has been shaky, the Yankees are banking on him to provide crucial innings. Winans, who was called up primarily to fill a short-term need, will continue to be part of the team's depth options moving forward.

As the Yankees gear up for a pivotal three-game series against the Athletics, manager Aaron Boone is still undecided on his Sunday starter. The options are Marcus Stroman and Allan Winans, both of whom were set to throw side sessions on Friday. Stroman, struggling with a 6.97 ERA in his rehab starts after knee inflammation, faces pressure after his latest outing, where he allowed five earned runs in 3.2 innings. Winans, who debuted in the majors with a 0.90 ERA in Triple-A, allowed four runs over 4.1 innings in his first start but has shown promise.

The Yankees will be without J.C. Escarra due to paternity leave, and Boone indicated they might not make any roster moves, as Escarra is expected back Sunday. Additionally, utility player Braden Shewmake and outfielder Everson Pereira are also unavailable, adding to their challenges as they face left-handed pitcher JP Sears. Boone confirmed that Jonathan Loáisiga is still recovering from an illness, which could further limit the bullpen options.

The Yankees have not been eagerly anticipating the return of Marcus Stroman, who struggled with an 11.57 ERA before his injury. However, as the 2025 season progresses, they could use a league-average performance from him. With Ryan Yarbrough out, Allan Winans made a spot start, but the Yankees suffered a 6-1 loss to the Reds. Stroman's recent rehab outing with the Double-A Somerset Patriots was disappointing, yielding 5 earned runs over 3.2 innings, raising concerns among fans and management.

Allan Winans, a name not initially on the radar for New York Yankees fans, is making headlines after being called up from Triple-A Scranton, where he boasted an impressive 0.90 ERA with a staggering 7-0 record. His minor league dominance included an incredible performance where he struck out 10 of 11 batters, marking a feat not seen since 1961. Winans' journey has been anything but typical, having been a 17th-round pick by the Mets in 2018 and later picked up by the Yankees. Despite a rocky start in the majors with the Braves, where he posted a 7.20 ERA and allowed nine home runs in 40 innings, he now has a chance to secure a spot in the Yankees' rotation as they look to bolster their pitching staff amidst injuries to key players like Marcus Stroman.

Winans made his MLB debut in July and showed potential with a scoreless outing against the Mets. As the Yankees recover from injuries, he could provide much-needed support down the stretch. Scouts have noted that while he may not possess overwhelming stuff, his command and competitive nature could prove invaluable for the Yankees’ playoff push.

Allan Winans is making a strong case for a permanent spot in the Yankees' rotation with his impressive performance in the minors, boasting a 0.90 ERA over 50 innings. His upcoming start against the Reds is crucial as the Yankees evaluate their options. With Marcus Stroman returning from injury, a decision looms whether to reinstate him, especially considering his poor start to the season.

Manager Aaron Boone hinted that Stroman’s return this weekend against the Athletics is contingent on Winans’ performance. If Winans can deliver a strong outing, he may become a valuable asset for the Yankees, potentially leading to a tough decision regarding Stroman's place in the lineup. With a favorable matchup on the horizon, the Yankees' rotation dynamics could shift significantly depending on this pivotal game.