In a remarkable moment during the Yankees' 4–2 victory over the Orioles, Jazz Chisholm Jr. lost both his cleats but still managed to score the game's first run. After losing a shoe turning third base, he collided with catcher Maverick Handley, which caused the other shoe to fly off. Despite this, Chisholm continued playing, demonstrating resilience and agility. He finished the game with two doubles and two RBIs, maintaining a .350 average since returning from an injury. His energetic play has revitalized the Yankees' lineup, adding pressure to opposing pitchers and enhancing their offensive strategy.

Chisholm’s unusual experience prompted a light-hearted comparison to Shoeless Joe Jackson, sparking laughter and reflection among teammates and fans alike. His ability to quickly adapt, even with a sudden footwear malfunction, illustrates his determination and skill. Chisholm's return has not only improved his personal stats but has also significantly impacted the overall performance of the Yankees, making them a team to watch as the season progresses.