The New York Yankees are facing a pivotal decision regarding their closer role as they prepare for the 2025 season. After a stellar performance in the second half of 2024, Luke Weaver, who assumed the closer position, is now competing with newly acquired Devin Williams for the job. Williams has struggled early in the season but showed signs of improvement following Weaver's hamstring injury, reclaiming the closer role after a brief demotion.

With Weaver returning from injury, Manager Aaron Boone has yet to confirm who will take the mound for save opportunities. Echoing past controversies, such as the 1978 season with Sparky Lyle and Goose Gossage, questions loom on whether Boone will stick with Williams or revert to Weaver. The recommendation is clear: the Yankees should embrace Williams as their primary closer, allowing him to settle into the role without further disruption.