Yankees manager Aaron Boone's recent decision to replace struggling infielder Oswaldo Peraza in a critical moment paid off when backup catcher J.C. Escarra secured a walk-off victory against the Padres with a sacrifice fly. Boone's gamble was met with mixed reactions; while some fans lauded his boldness, others questioned his faith in Peraza, who has struggled significantly this season. With DJ LeMahieu's imminent return, the competition for infield spots is intensifying, and Peraza's future with the Yankees could be at stake.

Peraza, a former top prospect, has underwhelmed with a .213 batting average and has become a liability at the plate. Boone's choice to trust a backup catcher over him raises questions about how the team views Peraza's potential as well as the overall depth of the lineup. As roster decisions loom, Peraza's position becomes increasingly precarious, particularly with LeMahieu's return and the promising performances from other infielders.