On May 5, 2025, Miles Mikolas and Pedro Pagés of the St. Louis Cardinals made history against the Pittsburgh Pirates. Mikolas allowed Oneil Cruz to reach base via a hit by pitch, only to witness Cruz's impressive stealing streak come to an abrupt halt. Pagés successfully gunned down Cruz, who had previously stolen 34 bases in a row. This marked Cruz's first caught stealing since April 2024, showcasing Pagés' improved defensive capabilities this season with a caught stealing percentage of 31.6%.

In that game, the Cardinals triumphed over the Pirates 6-3, with Pagés contributing significantly by going 2-for-3 at the plate. Mikolas pitched five innings, allowing three runs and earning a no-decision. This performance is indicative of how crucial both players are to the Cardinals' success in 2025, as Pagés continues to solidify his role as a reliable catcher.