As the 2025 MLB season approaches the All-Star break, the performance of several key pitchers has left fantasy managers frustrated. The focus turns to Bailey Ober, Kevin Gausman, Brandon Pfaadt, and Shane Baz, who have all struggled to meet expectations this season.

Ober, once a promising pitcher for the Minnesota Twins, has faced severe downturns, including a shocking 8.51 ERA in June. His drop in velocity and a lingering hip issue raise concerns about his role moving forward. Meanwhile, Gausman of the Toronto Blue Jays has displayed inconsistencies, with a recent stretch characterized by control issues leading to high ERAs.

Pfaadt, despite a solid start, has hit a regression phase, with an alarming ERA over the past month, and his strikeout rate has plummeted. Lastly, Baz, touted as a future ace for the Tampa Bay Rays, has also had mixed results, struggling with home runs though still showcasing potential. Each of these pitchers represents a unique case for fantasy managers weighing their options for the second half of the season.