The Cincinnati Bengals face a mixed response following their first-round selection of pass-rusher Shemar Stewart from Texas A&M in the 2025 NFL Draft. Despite his impressive physical metrics and potential to fill a critical role on the Bengals' defensive front, concerns linger regarding his production, having recorded only 4.5 sacks in three seasons. Analysts' evaluations have varied significantly, with grades ranging from a B by USA Today, highlighting Stewart's fit for the Bengals' defensive needs, to more skeptical assessments from CBS Sports and The Ringer, who awarded C grades, noting his raw instincts and need for development.

Amidst the uncertainty around Trey Hendrickson's future with the team, the Bengals opted for Stewart hoping his athleticism can translate into NFL success. While they addressed a pressing need on the edge, the pick has been criticized for a perceived lack of a safer, more polished alternative. This high-risk, high-reward strategy has left some experts pondering whether the Bengals can effectively nurture Stewart's potential, given their past struggles in developing talent.