The 2025 NFL Draft is already stirring debate among analysts and fans alike, particularly with several unexpected selections that defied consensus rankings. The Cleveland Browns' choice of quarterback Dillon Gabriel at 94th overall raised eyebrows, as he was generally rated much lower. His experience at the NCAA level is impressive, but concerns linger about his age and ability to make explosive plays.

Similarly, the choice of wide receiver Pat Bryant for the Browns at 74th overall also sparked discussions. Although he had a standout collegiate career, many believed other prospects were more deserving of a higher pick. The 49ers’ selection of linebacker Nick Martin has been criticized for similar reasons, as he was viewed as a reach based on size and ranking. The Lions’ decision to draft Isaac TeSlaa, who had a solid college career but was not projected to be a Day 2 pick, has also attracted scrutiny. The Colts and Texans further added to the controversy with their selections of cornerbacks Justin Walley and Jaylin Smith, respectively, both of whom were considered less likely to make an immediate impact.