Los Angeles Lakers' head coach JJ Redick faced criticism for playing only five players in the second half of Game 4 against the Minnesota Timberwolves, a game the Lakers ultimately lost 116-113. Despite building a 10-point lead by the end of the third quarter, the Lakers faltered in the final period. LeBron James defended Redick's decision on his 'Mind the Game' podcast, stating that the coaching staff made a judgment based on the game's momentum, and players felt responsible for the loss rather than blaming the coach.

James emphasized that none of the players questioned Redick, asserting that they collectively share the accountability for their defeat. The lineup featuring James, Luka Dončić, and Austin Reaves initially performed well but struggled in the fourth quarter, scoring a mere 19 points. Now, the Lakers and James face a crucial offseason as they contemplate roster improvements and his potential return for a 23rd season.

LeBron James and the Los Angeles Lakers faced a disappointing exit in the 2025 playoffs, falling to the Minnesota Timberwolves in the first round after a promising 50-win season. Under new coach JJ Redick, the Lakers secured the third seed but struggled with postseason adjustments, particularly in Game 4, where Redick's decision to play a small-ball lineup against the Timberwolves' towering frontcourt proved critical. James, along with players Austin Reaves, Dorian Finney-Smith, and Rui Hachimura, played the entire second half but could not overcome a late-game collapse.

Redick's controversial strategies, including using five players for the entire second half, led to criticism, especially concerning James, who at 40 years old, managed to score 27 points but eventually showed signs of fatigue. Despite the criticism, James stated he was comfortable with the minutes played, emphasizing the importance of the game and the need for the team to make crucial plays. The Lakers' loss highlighted the challenges of managing aging star players while striving for playoff success.

In his inaugural season as head coach of the Los Angeles Lakers, JJ Redick has demonstrated his ability to adapt and lead a team undergoing significant changes. Hired last June, Redick faced skepticism due to his lack of coaching experience, but he successfully guided the Lakers to a surprising third-place finish in the Western Conference. Although the team was eliminated in the first round of the playoffs by the Minnesota Timberwolves, Redick's leadership has instilled a renewed sense of optimism for the Lakers' future.

Redick reflected on the challenges faced throughout the season, expressing a desire for improvement and emphasizing the importance of self-evaluation. He noted the necessity of addressing the team's chronic issues while fostering an environment conducive to growth. Under his guidance, the Lakers are shifting towards a more analytical approach, improving their roster depth, and positioning themselves as serious title contenders moving forward.

Kenny Atkinson secured the NBA's Coach of the Year award, propelling the Cleveland Cavaliers to a remarkable 64-18 season. His predecessor, J.B. Bickerstaff, who achieved success with the Detroit Pistons, was also in contention. Meanwhile, JJ Redick, despite the Lakers' impressive third seed finish in the West, received only sixth place votes due to his inexperience as a head coach. Critics questioned his appointment, fearing he might be overly influenced by his friendship with LeBron James. However, Redick's ability to navigate roster changes and performance slumps showcased his potential as a capable coach.

The Los Angeles Lakers, under first-year head coach JJ Redick, finished the 2025 NBA season with a 50-32 record, capturing their first Pacific Division title since 2020. This remarkable achievement came despite a significant midseason trade, sending franchise star Anthony Davis to the Dallas Mavericks in exchange for Luka Doncic. Despite a disappointing playoff exit in the first round against the Minnesota Timberwolves, the Lakers' performance exceeded expectations.

Although Redick did not secure a top-five spot in the Coach of the Year voting, he did receive five third-place votes, indicating a recognition of his impact. The debate surrounding the coaching awards sparked heated discussions among fans, highlighting the competitive landscape of the league.