The Toronto Blue Jays, once leading the American League East, have spiraled into a five-game losing streak, plummeting to a disappointing 13-15 record. Recent games against the New York Yankees showcased a familiar pattern: a lack of offensive production. Even with 11 hits in the first game of a recent doubleheader, only two were with runners in scoring position, leading to an 11-2 loss. In the second game, they managed just one run on three hits, falling 5-1.

The Blue Jays now have the fourth-worst offense across MLB, struggling particularly with runners in scoring position, hitting just .585. This poor performance has been compounded by the pitching struggles of Kevin Gausman, whose recent outing featured an alarming 53 pitches in one inning. As the Jays head into a challenging series against the Boston Red Sox, fans are left wondering if their early season promise can be salvaged.

The Toronto Blue Jays have struggled early in the 2025 MLB season, starting with a 13-14 record that indicates unfulfilled potential. Despite this, their pitching rotation has been a bright spot, ranking 11th in the league with a 3.73 team ERA, slightly better than last year's average. However, the performance of ace Kevin Gausman has raised eyebrows; he tied the record for the most pitches thrown in a single inning by a Blue Jays pitcher with 53, a stat not seen since 1998. Gausman has had a mixed season, with his ERA sitting at 4.50 after six starts, reflecting struggles particularly evident in his last outing against the New York Yankees, where he allowed six runs in just 2.2 innings. John Schneider's managerial decisions, especially regarding the rotation and player utilization, are under scrutiny as the team navigates this rough patch.

The New York Yankees showcased impressive plate discipline, tallying six walks in a pivotal third inning against Kevin Gausman, leading to a six-run rally that propelled them to an 11-2 victory over the Toronto Blue Jays. Manager Aaron Boone praised the team’s approach, emphasizing the necessity of patience against a pitcher of Gausman’s caliber.

After trailing 1-0, the Yankees drew consecutive walks from Oswaldo Cabrera and Ben Rice before Aaron Judge delivered a scorching line drive to load the bases. Cody Bellinger tied the game with a sacrifice fly, setting the stage for a cascade of walks from Gausman, who struggled under the pressure. Anthony Volpe added a solo home run later, securing the Yankees’ offensive dominance.

Rain on Saturday forced the postponement of the Yankees' game against the Toronto Blue Jays, coinciding with Aaron Judge's birthday. The match will now take place as part of a doubleheader on Sunday, with the first game starting shortly after the originally scheduled game at 1:35 p.m. EDT. Max Fried was slated to pitch for the Yankees, while Kevin Gausman was set to take the mound for Toronto. Judge, celebrating his 33rd birthday, has a strong history of performances on this date, boasting a .333 batting average with two home runs in six games.

This matchup marks the first series of the season between these AL East rivals. The Yankees dropped the opening game of the series 4-2, with closer Devin Williams suffering his first blown save. Judge currently leads the league in several batting categories, including average and OPS, showcasing his value to fantasy teams.