Tylor Megill continued his early-season pattern of strong April performances but faltered again in May, allowing four earned runs against the Chicago Cubs. He struggled with command, failing to last five innings for the second consecutive outing. Despite his shortcomings, the Mets' Brett Baty showcased his power, hitting two home runs and bringing the team close before falling short in a 6-5 loss. The rookie pitcher Cade Horton made his MLB debut, impressing with a solid performance that included five strikeouts over four innings, leading the Cubs to victory.

The game had its turning points, notably Baty's three-run homer that narrowed the gap to 4-3, followed by another blast in the eighth to bring the score to 6-5. However, the Cubs' closer Porter Hodge sealed the win with a double play in the final frame, handing the Mets another tough loss. The matchup underscored the Mets' need for consistency and highlighted the Cubs' pitching depth, especially with Horton emerging as a promising talent.