Ben Lively's season is officially over as the Cleveland Guardians announced he requires Tommy John surgery due to a UCL injury, casting uncertainty over his recovery timeline that could extend into 2026. Last season, Lively posted a career-best 3.81 ERA, but his 2025 performance showed promise with a 3.22 ERA in 44.2 innings until the injury forced his shutdown. His absence puts additional strain on a Guardians rotation already missing Shane Bieber, who is similarly recovering from Tommy John surgery.

The Guardians' current rotation now leans on Tanner Bibee, Gavin Williams, Luis Ortiz, and Logan Allen, with rookie Slade Cecconi stepping in. These arms must step up in Lively's absence, particularly as the team navigates a tough stretch. The impact on fantasy leagues could be significant, especially considering Lively's previous trajectory as a reliable starter.