Qwiket Logo
Cleveland Guardians
Cleveland Guardians
David Fry
David Fry
David Fry
David Fry
NFL
NHL
MLB
NBA
MLB:
Arizona Diamondbacks
Atlanta Braves
Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
Chicago Cubs
Chicago White Sox
Cincinnati Reds
Cleveland Guardians
Colorado Rockies
Detroit Tigers
Houston Astros
Kansas City Royals
Los Angeles Angels
Los Angeles Dodgers
Miami Marlins
Milwaukee Brewers
Minnesota Twins
New York Yankees
Oakland Athletics
Philadelphia Phillies
Pittsburgh Pirates
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
Seattle Mariners
St. Louis Cardinals
Tampa Bay Rays
Texas Rangers
Toronto Blue Jays
Athletics
New York Mets
Washington Nationals
Qwiket Logo
IN-FOCUS
✕
Go To Full MLB Digest
September 12, 2025
Best MLB Player Prop Bets - Home Run Props for Today (9/12/2025) | Fantasy News
Kipp Heisterman
Rotoballer
Best MLB Player Prop Bets - Home Run Props for Today (9/12/2025) | Fantasy News

Carson Kelly rides a hot streak into a Cubs–Rays setup, offering a value HR prop as he’s mashed lately and routinely handles right-handers. The matchup leans in his favor with Baz on the bump and a Rays bullpen that has yielded several homers.

Josh Bell taps a favorable angle against Mitch Keller, using Bell’s recent power surge and Keller’s propensity to surrender homers, especially to righty hitters. The price on Bell’s over 0.5 HR is attractive given the season-long power and the favorable righty-righty dynamic.

David Fry is a deeper flyer vs Martin Perez, leveraging Fry’s lefty-mower profile and Perez’s velocity weakness. Guardians’ bullpen risk adds uncertainty, but Fry’s history against lefties makes this a compelling contrarian spike.

Jackson Chourio closes with a high-upside over 0.5 HR vs Pallante, riding a recent .981 OPS and lefty power numbers. Pallante has struggled to suppress left-handed thump, and Chourio’s recent form makes this a prime target in value-driven rounds.

Which HR prop offers the best ROI among Kelly, Bell, Fry, and Chourio tonight?How do weather and park factors affect tonight’s HR targets?What stacks maximize value in a round robin with these four players?If one prop fails early, which backup target maintains the portfolio’s edge?
Mentions:
@Carson Kelly | Chicago Cubs | MLB
@Carson Kelly | Chicago Cubs | MLB
Chicago Cubs | MLB
Chicago Cubs | MLB
@David Fry | Cleveland Guardians | MLB
@David Fry | Cleveland Guardians | MLB
@Jackson Chourio | Milwaukee Brewers | MLB
@Jackson Chourio | Milwaukee Brewers | MLB
@Josh Bell | Washington Nationals | MLB
@Josh Bell | Washington Nationals | MLB

https://www.rotoballer.com/best-mlb-player-prop-be..

Cleveland Guardians:
Logan Allen (9)
Pedro Avila (29)
Tanner Bibee (266)
Joey Cantillo (47)
Emmanuel Clase (3)
Daniel Espino (2)
Hunter Gaddis (78)
Connor Gillispie (0)
Sam Hentges (0)
Tim Herrin (33)
Ben Lively (140)
Triston McKenzie (6)
Erik Sabrowski (7)
Cade Smith (72)
Trevor Stephan (0)
Peter Strzelecki (2)
Andrew Walters (3)
Gavin Williams (1)
Bo Naylor (134)
Gabriel Arias (1)
Juan Brito (6)
David Fry (192)
Kyle Manzardo (82)
Jose Ramirez (619)
Brayan Rocchio (133)
Daniel Schneemann (1)
Will Brennan (59)
Steven Kwan (1)
Angel Martinez (13)
Jhonkensy Noel (1)
Johnathan Rodriguez (0)
Lane Thomas (127)
George Valera (0)
Manager Stephen Vogt (0)
Carlos Hernandez (0)
Matt Festa (1)
Luis Ortiz (28)
Kolby Allard (0)
Slade Cecconi (34)
Nolan Jones (11)
Franco Aleman (0)
Nic Enright (0)
Doug Nikhazy (6)
Petey Halpin (0)
Shane Bieber (7)
Will Wilson (2)
Jakob Junis (1)
Carlos Santana (2)