The Colorado Rockies are facing a dismal season, yet catcher Hunter Goodman has been selected as an All-Star, a rarity considering the team's performance. While Goodman may not rank among the top catchers in the National League, he certainly stands out as a bright spot for the Rockies, arguably making him the second-best catcher in the league for the first half of the season. This selection emphasizes the rule that every MLB team must have at least one representative in the All-Star Game, regardless of their overall success.

The history of MLB All-Stars is filled with stories of unexpected selections, especially among lesser-known players who have made the cut. It highlights that many athletes, despite their limited career statistics, find themselves honored with an All-Star title due to quirks of timing, fan votes, or unique circumstances. This season's All-Star roster also serves as a reminder of the randomness that can define baseball, where even players with a checkered past can enjoy moments of glory.