Heading into Week 16 of the 2025 fantasy baseball season, cutting players from your roster becomes more critical as underperformers emerge. Notably, Drew Rasmussen of the Tampa Bay Rays is under scrutiny after a decent stat line, but concerns surrounding his limited innings cap make him a candidate for drop in most leagues. Brenton Doyle of the Colorado Rockies has struggled significantly on the road, suggesting he might only be a viable option in deeper leagues. Meanwhile, Jack Flaherty from the Detroit Tigers appears to show signs of rebound despite an inflated ERA, making him worth holding onto.

Adolis Garcia of the Texas Rangers is intriguing as a potential trade candidate, with recent performance indicating he might be turning a corner. Jackson Merrill of the San Diego Padres, after a rocky start, is also on the hot seat after a two-homer game, leaving fantasy managers pondering his future. Lastly, Salvador Perez and Ian Happ, both experiencing slumps, show volatility typical of catchers while also still holding some value due to their respective roles. This week’s Cut List urges careful consideration and strategic thinking as you manage your roster.