The National League appears to be rich in talent, while the American League boasts an impressive array of top-tier starting pitchers. Leading the charge is Detroit's Tarik Skubal, who has emerged as one of the game's elite pitchers, following a stellar 2024 season where he won the Cy Young Award. Yankees' Max Fried has made a significant impact since joining New York, consistently showcasing his skills. Meanwhile, the Texas Rangers' Jacob deGrom, despite injury concerns, remains a formidable presence when healthy.

Garrett Crochet of the Boston Red Sox has also established himself, leading in strikeouts and innings pitched, while showing great potential to dominate opposing hitters. The upcoming All-Star Game is set to feature these elite pitchers, and Yankees manager Aaron Boone faces the challenging task of selecting the starter. Each candidate brings a unique set of skills and narratives that make the decision complex, especially considering their recent performances and the fan interest they generate.