Pro Football Focus recently ranked the Indianapolis Colts' running back unit as the 16th best in the NFL, indicating a mid-level performance. While Jonathan Taylor returned to form with a solid 1,400-yard rushing season in 2024, he also recorded a career-low 57.1 PFF overall grade. This drop is attributed to his struggles in breaking tackles despite his high yardage. The Colts bolstered their backfield by acquiring Khalil Herbert, who has also faced challenges in his career.

Moreover, the selection of DJ Giddens in the fifth round is seen as a promising addition, given his impressive 93.4 rushing grade at Kansas State. The Colts' depth appears improved from the previous season, but Taylor will need to validate his capabilities beyond relying on excellent blocking to increase his overall value in fantasy leagues.