The Indianapolis Colts must take a serious look at their quarterback situation as they head into the 2026 offseason. After selecting Anthony Richardson at No. 4 overall just three years ago, his lackluster performance has left fans questioning his future as a starter. Poor passing grades from Pro Football Focus, combined with his limited playing time, mean he needs a breakout season in 2025 to secure his position. Meanwhile, Daniel Jones, currently on a one-year deal, may need to step up significantly to lead the team to playoff contention.

If Richardson fails to develop, the Colts could find themselves selecting another quarterback in 2026, potentially leading to sweeping changes across the organization, including at head coach and GM. The Colts need to find stability at the quarterback position to maximize their roster talent and return to postseason relevancy.