In the 2025 NFL Draft, the Indianapolis Colts made a notable decision by selecting cornerback Justin Walley in the third round, despite him being ranked No. 194 on consensus boards. Area scout Tyler Hughes emphasized Walley’s versatility, intelligence, and competitive nature, traits that are crucial for a cornerback in today's game. His impressive 4.4 speed, coupled with a willingness to perform at the NFL Combine while nursing a wrist injury, showcased his determination and skill. Walley's ability to play both inside and outside will be instrumental in fitting into the Colts’ defensive strategy under Lou Anarumo.

Walley's statistics speak volumes; he ended his college career with seven interceptions and 16 pass breakups. This production, alongside his tenacity, caught the eye of General Manager Chris Ballard, who praised his capability to perform under pressure. As he joins a revamped Colts cornerback room, Walley is set to compete for a starting position against players like Jaylon Jones and JuJu Brents. The Colts believe that increasing competition will enhance overall team performance, particularly in crucial game moments.