The Indianapolis Colts' quarterback battle shapes up to be a key storyline heading into the 2025 season, with Daniel Jones and Anthony Richardson as the main contenders. While Richardson has shown flashes of potential, his poor completion percentage and turnover issues raise concerns about his readiness. Conversely, Jones has experience and a playoff victory but has struggled to consistently deliver in recent seasons. The outcome of this competition will significantly impact rookie tight end Tyler Warren's fantasy value, as he could emerge as the team's top target, depending on which quarterback wins the job.

Jonathan Taylor's return to form also plays a crucial role. After an injury-plagued previous season, Taylor's performance as a top-tier running back hinges on the effectiveness of the Colts' passing game. With both quarterbacks needing to refine their decision-making and accuracy, the Colts' offense could face challenges. However, if Richardson, known for his rushing ability, wins the starting job, it may unlock more fantasy potential for players like Warren and receiver Michael Pittman Jr. Ultimately, the quarterback decision holds the keys to the Colts' offensive success in the upcoming season.