Tuesday MLB DFS on 9/9/2025 features 11-game slates with smart value plays and solid stacks. Emmet Sheehan tops the pitcher plays for DK/FD with a juicy matchup and Dodgers’ support, while George Kirby and Zebby Matthews give solid SP options at varying price points. Infielders include Nick Kurtz, Max Muncy back from IL, Luke Keaschall, and Matt McLain, with Blaze Alexander stepping into value spots. Outfielders spotlight Fernando Tatis Jr., George Springer, and Josh Lowe, plus Padres and Rays stacks as core upside plays.

Injury news and lineup updates shape the night, but the plan hinges on exploiting righty-lefty matchups and leveraging mid-price talent with homer potential. A Padres-heavy approach around Tatis Jr. and a complementary Cats-in-play from Springer and Lowe set the table for high-ceiling day games. Use premium tools and quick lineup pivots as the slate evolves.

Thunder Dan’s guide emphasizes elite arms, cost-efficient bats, and positional flexibility to build balanced lineups on FanDuel and DraftKings, all anchored by 7:05 PM EST starts.