The Carolina Panthers have generated a mix of optimism and skepticism following an eventful offseason, as highlighted by ESPN analyst Seth Walder's recent grades on NFL teams for their offseason performance. Despite the anticipation among fans, Walder raised concerns regarding some of the Panthers' significant investments, particularly a four-year, $100 million extension for cornerback Jaycee Horn, which he deemed overly generous. Additionally, Walder criticized the signing of defensive lineman Tershawn Wharton, suggesting that his three-year, $45 million deal with over $30 million guaranteed might not align with his past performance, particularly his low pass rush win rate from last season.

Walder emphasized the potential pitfalls of Wharton's contract, especially considering the absence of Chris Jones, who previously helped elevate Wharton's game by drawing double teams. His doubts extend to Wharton's run-stopping abilities, a crucial facet for success in the trenches. As offseason grades are finalized, the Panthers find themselves balancing high expectations with the inherent risks associated with their strategic decisions.