Abdul Carter arrives in New York with game-changing potential for the Giants on Week 1. The rookie edge can line up across from interior disruptors and veteran stoppers, giving New York four rush threats at once. Early preseason efficiency (5 pressures, 30% win rate on limited snaps) plus a favorable opener against a Washington line dealing with Cosmi injury fuels optimism, yet historical rookie outcomes tempers the hype. The mix of Carter’s speed, power and elite flexibility could redefine NYG’s pass rush across the 2025 season.

Kapadia’s caution anchors the analysis: top-five rookies seldom post double-digit sacks as rookies. If Carter picks up reps quickly and the Giants maximize their front with Lawrence, Burns and Thibodeaux alongside him, NYG could threaten a multi-weapon pressure unit. Washington’s shorthanded protection and Cosmi absence could be a testing ground for Carter’s immediate impact and fantasy upside.