The Buffalo Bills have sparked debates surrounding their 'Mount Rushmore' of players since the 2000 NFL season. Notable names considered include Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas, but Bleacher Report has narrowed it down to four key figures representing a significant era of the franchise. The chosen players are quarterback Josh Allen, offensive tackle Dion Dawkins, linebacker Matt Milano, and defensive tackle Kyle Williams.

Each of these athletes has contributed to the Bills' journey from playoff droughts to recent successes, showcasing their impact on the franchise's legacy.