Since taking over as head coach of the Buffalo Bills in 2017, Sean McDermott has led the franchise to impressive regular-season success, boasting an 86-45 record and securing five consecutive AFC East titles. However, his playoff record remains a concern, with the Bills repeatedly falling short of a Super Bowl appearance. Despite a strong showing in the playoffs, including six wins over five seasons, McDermott's inability to defeat Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs has left fans and analysts questioning his status among the league's elite coaches.

Currently ranked No. 11 by Pro Football Network, McDermott must find a way to break through the playoff ceiling, especially with the looming threat of the Chiefs. If he can guide Buffalo to their first Super Bowl victory by 2025, his standing among top coaches could rise significantly. However, if the trend of playoff failures continues, a difficult decision may be necessary regarding his future with the team.