The San Francisco 49ers executed nine picks in the 2025 NFL Draft, with an emphasis on defensive talent, selecting six defensive players. Mykel Williams, their first-round choice, faces high expectations. However, critiques arise regarding the lack of offensive reinforcement, particularly with Brock Purdy's contract status still unresolved, thus raising eyebrows about their draft strategy.

Critics, including the Pro Football Network, argue that the 49ers failed to address significant offensive gaps, especially with the departures of key players like Deebo Samuel and the injury concerns surrounding Christian McCaffrey. Conversely, some analysts, like Chris Simms from NBC, have praised the 49ers' draft choices, asserting that their focus on defense aligns with their overall team philosophy under coach Kyle Shanahan.

The 49ers' approach has generated mixed reactions, signaling potential risks and rewards. Time will ultimately reveal the effectiveness of this draft as the team looks to solidify both its defensive and offensive strategies for the upcoming season.